Logo

Coach of the Year 2025: At This Point, Who Deserves It More Than Kyle Shanahan ?

SANTA CLARA, Calif. — Week 13 closed with an 8–4 record, the top of the NFC West, and a roster that most head coaches in the league would have surrendered to long ago. But Kyle Shanahan isn’t most coaches. He just led the San Francisco 49ers to a 27–17 win over the Seahawks without Brock Purdy, without Brandon Aiyuk, with a banged-up George Kittle, and with Nick Bosa and Fred Warner playing only half the game. In a season where nearly every star has battled injuries, Shanahan has kept his team functioning like a disciplined, resilient machine. “If this isn’t the Coach of the Year, then who is?” Colin Cowherd said last week — and the line has quickly become a rallying cry among 49ers fans.

What Shanahan has accomplished this season almost defies logic. He’s operating with the most injured roster in the NFL, according to the Man-Games Lost Index, yet his offense still averages 28.4 points per game — third best in the league. He revived Mac Jones, once labeled a “fallen prospect,” helping him win three of his last four starts with a passer rating over 100. He turned Joshua Dobbs from clipboard holder into a Monday Night Football winner. He elevated Isaac Guerendo, Ronnie Bell, and a cast of unheralded players into All-Pro-level contributors at the exact moments the team needed them most. No complaints, no drama — just a new playbook every week designed around whoever is still standing.

After the win over the Rams, Shanahan made a statement that has become the defining theme of the 49ers’ season: “I don’t care who we have. I care what we do with the ones we have left.” And the entire NFL is watching him prove that philosophy true. Coach of the Year often goes to the one who battles adversity — Kevin O’Connell with his 13–4 Vikings, Brian Daboll taking the Giants from 4–13 to the playoffs — but Shanahan is fighting a tougher war: keeping the 49ers in the NFC’s top three despite a level of injury attrition no contender has matched.

Kyle Brandt of NFL Network said it plainly: “He’s having the best coaching season of his career — maybe the best we’ve seen in twenty years.” And he’s not wrong. Shane Steichen has the Colts trending up. Dan Campbell has the Lions soaring. But neither is winning eight games with a roster this battered, this depleted, this constantly reshuffled. Every week, the 49ers look like a different team — and yet, every week, they still look like a winning one. That doesn’t happen without Shanahan.

Five games remain, but the question is no longer “Will Shanahan be among the finalists?” The only question left is: Who could possibly deserve it more? Coach of the Year 2025 already feels decided. And this time, no one will dare say Kyle Shanahan got “snubbed.”

10 views
Just 1 Hour After Being Waived by the Bills, the 49ers Immediately Sign a Pro Bowl WR — a 3-Time Super Bowl Champion Deal That Supercharges the Offense Ahead of the Playoffs, Eyes Locked on the Super Bowl
Dec 30, 2025 Santa Clara, California — The message from the San Francisco 49ers could not have been clearer: December leaves no room for hesitation. The moment the Buffalo Bills decided to move on, much of the league expected the usual pause — a waiting game, quiet evaluations, a market that takes a breath before acting. The 49ers didn’t wait. Roughly one hour later, San Francisco moved with precision, securing Mecole Hardman — a player whose résumé carries exactly what contenders crave when January approaches: elite speed, playoff composure, and championship DNA. This wasn’t simply San Francisco “adding another receiver.”This was San Francisco adding the right kind of weapon — the type who can tilt the rhythm of a game with a single touch. Hardman is built for momentum swings. He doesn’t need volume to change outcomes. One jet motion, one perfectly timed burst, one touch in space can force an entire defense to panic, rotate coverage, and play faster than it wants to. That’s how postseason games break open. The résumé supports the belief.Hardman is a three-time Super Bowl champion, a proven contributor on the sport’s biggest stage — a player who has operated inside high-speed, high-pressure offenses where every snap carries consequence. At his peak, he has been a true vertical stressor, someone defenses must respect on motions, quick touches, and explosive concepts designed to stretch the field horizontally and vertically. Shortly after the deal was finalized, Hardman delivered a message that immediately resonated throughout the building: “I’ve been on top of this league before, and I didn’t choose San Francisco just to be here. I chose the 49ers because I believe this is a place that can take me back to the top one more time.” Beyond the receiver label, Hardman’s value has always extended into the game’s hidden margins — special-situation moments that quietly decide playoff games long before the final whistle. Field position. Defensive hesitation. One sudden spark that changes how an opponent calls the next series. For the 49ers, the signal is unmistakable: this is an all-in move.Teams don’t win in January with only a Plan A. They win with answers — wrinkles that punish overaggressive fronts, speed that stretches pursuit angles, and personnel that prevents defenses from sitting comfortably in familiar looks. Hardman adds another layer to San Francisco’s offense, another problem coordinators must solve, and another way to manufacture a momentum flip when drives tighten. Just as important, the signing sends a jolt through the locker room.The 49ers aren’t preparing to simply enter the postseason. They’re preparing to arrive with options — a player who can widen throwing windows, lighten defensive boxes through speed alone, and turn a routine snap into a sudden shift in control. If everything clicks the way San Francisco believes it can, Mecole Hardman won’t be remembered for the timing of the signing. He’ll be remembered for a moment — one route, one burst, one touch — when the postseason demands something special. And for the 49ers, that’s the entire point: stack every possible advantage now, and chase the only destination that truly matters — the Super Bowl.