"IT WASN’T A FAIR WIN" — Titans HC Mike McCoy Accuses 49ers of "Illegal Tactics" After Lopsided Loss, Brock Purdy Fires Back and Shuts Down the Narrative
December 15, 2025
What should have been a routine postgame breakdown following the San Francisco 49ers’ commanding 37–24 win over the Tennessee Titans quickly turned into a heated controversy, as Titans head coach Mike McCoy delivered stunning accusations that shifted the conversation from football to fairness and honor.
Instead of focusing on tactical shortcomings or execution gaps, McCoy chose to ignite a public dispute, framing the loss as something darker than the scoreboard suggested — a move that instantly grabbed the NFL’s attention.
“That wasn’t a fair win. What happened out there was a victory without honor,” McCoy said, implying that San Francisco crossed ethical lines to secure the outcome.
The comment spread rapidly across league circles, triggering intense debate among fans, analysts, and former players. Some questioned whether the allegation held weight, while many saw it as an emotional reaction from a coach reeling after a lopsided defeat.
San Francisco’s response came swiftly — and calmly. Quarterback Brock Purdy, who controlled the game with precision and composure, did not shy away from the controversy and firmly defended his teammates and the team’s preparation.
“We prepared the right way, and we played disciplined football,” Purdy said. “Everything that happened on that field came from focus, preparation, and execution — not from any kind of tactics outside the rules.”
The film strongly supports Purdy’s words. The 49ers dictated tempo from start to finish, dominated time of possession, converted consistently on third down, and applied relentless pressure on Tennessee’s offense. These are the trademarks of a cohesive, well-coached team — not one searching for questionable advantages.

The 37–24 final score reflected sustained control, not isolated breaks. San Francisco built drives methodically, defended with sound positioning and pursuit, and forced the Titans into desperation mode long before the final whistle. In games like this, frustration often turns into accusation more easily than reflection.
Around the league, veteran voices were quick to note that emotional postgame remarks frequently say more about pain than proof. When one team controls every phase of the game, public blame can feel more comforting than confronting internal shortcomings.
For the Titans, the real work now lies inward — studying the film, addressing breakdowns, and correcting flaws exposed under pressure. Public accusations rarely provide solutions that preparation and accountability can.
The 49ers, meanwhile, brushed off the noise entirely. Inside their locker room, the message remained unchanged: stay focused, stay disciplined, and let performance speak louder than words.
As the dust settles, the NFL is left with a familiar reminder. Football’s loudest arguments often erupt after losses. But its truths are usually decided quietly — between the lines. And in this game, San Francisco owned them from start to finish.
May You Like

From Unforgettable Moments to Eternal Glory, Roger Craig Takes His Place Among Football Immortals











