Logo

Just Hours After a Former 49ers Super Bowl Pillar Claimed He Could “Figure Out” Brock Purdy Ahead of the 49ers–Colts Matchup, Hall of Famer Joe Montana Fired Back

San Francisco, California – December 18, 2025

As Week 16 approaches and the NFC playoff race tightens, the matchup between the San Francisco 49ers and Indianapolis Colts has suddenly drawn heightened attention across the NFL. Scheduled for December 23 at Levi’s Stadium, the game carries major postseason implications — and now, added pregame tension sparked by pointed remarks before kickoff.

What initially appeared to be a standard late-season interconference matchup escalated this week when a familiar voice from San Francisco’s past spoke up. A former defensive cornerstone of the 49ers, now anchoring the Colts’ defensive front, suggested his deep understanding of the organization could play a role in slowing down Brock Purdy.

That voice belongs to DeForest Buckner, the defensive tackle who helped define San Francisco’s defense during its run to Super Bowl LIV in the 2019 season. Selected seventh overall in the 2016 NFL Draft, Buckner quickly emerged as one of the league’s premier interior defensive linemen, earning All-Pro honors and serving as the foundation of the 49ers’ front before being traded in 2020 due to salary-cap constraints.

Since arriving in Indianapolis, Buckner has continued to establish himself as a central figure along the Colts’ defensive line. As the leader of the unit, he routinely commands double teams, generates interior pressure, and remains instrumental in how Indianapolis constructs its defensive game plans each week.

Ahead of Week 16, Buckner acknowledged that his familiarity with San Francisco’s structure and philosophy still carries weight — particularly when facing a quarterback now tasked with leading the franchise forward.

“I played in San Francisco for four years, won accolades there, and I think I understand that team better than anyone,” Buckner said confidently. “Purdy has been leading the 49ers well and they’ve been winning lately, but with my knowledge of how they operate, I believe I can figure him out.”

Those comments quickly reached the Bay Area and, just hours later, drew a response from one of the most authoritative voices in franchise history. Joe Montana, the Hall of Fame quarterback and four-time Super Bowl champion, publicly defended Purdy while directly challenging Buckner’s assessment.

“The offense doesn’t operate the same way it used to, and Brock has led that change,” Montana said. “He’s decisive, calm under pressure, and trusted throughout the locker room. Knowing the old system doesn’t guarantee success against the new one.”

Montana’s response echoed the broader confidence surrounding Purdy, who has helped guide the 49ers toward a more adaptable, efficient offensive identity. Within the organization, there is a belief that relying on institutional memory alone will not be enough to disrupt a team that has evolved significantly since Buckner’s tenure.

When the 49ers and Colts meet in Week 16, the matchup will represent more than a battle for playoff positioning. It will be a clash between past familiarity and present execution — between a former defensive pillar who knows where the franchise has been and a quarterback determined to show where it is going next.

14 views
While Levi’s Stadium was shrouded in disappointment, Brock Purdy didn’t leave the court in silence – He went straight to Sam Darnold and delivered a chilling message about the next playoff battle
Santa Clara, California – January 4, 2026. Levi’s Stadium slowly emptied as the final whistle sounded. The 13–3 loss to the Seattle Seahawks not only snapped the San Francisco 49ers’ six-game winning streak, but stripped them of the NFC’s top seed and home-field advantage on the final weekend of the regular season. A painful fall, at the one moment they could least afford it. In that setting, Brock Purdy didn’t react like a quarterback coming off the most deflating loss of the season. Instead of heading straight to the tunnel with the rest of his teammates, Purdy turned back toward midfield and walked directly to Sam Darnold — the man who had just helped Seattle control the game from start to finish. There was no argument, no extra gesture. Just a few words delivered calmly and with intent: “See you in a couple of weeks.” It didn’t sound like frustration. It sounded like a date already circled. The game itself offered little comfort for San Francisco. Seattle smothered the 49ers from the opening drives, holding the entire offense to just 176 total yards. Christian McCaffrey was bottled up, and Purdy spent the night throwing under pressure, forced into quick decisions and short completions. He finished with 127 yards and an interception — numbers that reflected how thoroughly the Seahawks dictated the terms. Yet the most telling moments came off the stat sheet. On the sideline, Purdy never detached. Between series, he stayed engaged with his offensive line and receivers, talking through missed opportunities and reinforcing composure. There was no visible frustration, no searching for excuses — just a steady effort to keep the group grounded as the game slipped away. “We don’t judge ourselves by one game. What matters is how you respond, how you get back up, and how you play when things are at their toughest.” That mindset defined the 49ers’ locker room after the loss. The disappointment was obvious, but panic was absent. Veterans understood that the postseason doesn’t care how a team arrives — only how it handles adversity once it’s there. And for San Francisco, the role of road warrior is hardly unfamiliar. Head coach Kyle Shanahan didn’t shy away from reality. He acknowledged that the team had made its own path harder by losing home-field advantage, guaranteeing a more demanding playoff road. But there was no sense of resignation — only acceptance and a focus on what comes next. Inside the room, leaders like George Kittle and Fred Warner echoed the same message: the playoffs are a new season. What happened against Seattle won’t be forgotten, but it won’t define them either. The frustration remains — not as a burden, but as fuel. In that context, Purdy’s moment at midfield carried weight beyond a single exchange. It symbolized how this team chooses to confront setbacks — not by shrinking, not by disappearing, not by walking away quietly. The 49ers are willing to face the harder road, eyes forward, ready for whoever stands across from them again. The playoffs are shaped by the smallest details. A glance. A sentence. A moment after defeat. Levi’s Stadium closed the night in silence, but for Brock Purdy and the San Francisco 49ers, it wasn’t an ending — it was the beginning of the most revealing test of their season.