Steelers Legend Bill Cowher Blasts Offense, Calls Out Arthur Smith’s Directionless Scheme

Pittsburgh, PA — September 23, 2025 — The Pittsburgh Steelers’ offense has drawn sharp criticism from franchise icon Bill Cowher, whose blistering remarks targeted coordinator Arthur Smith and a faltering offensive line. Speaking on a local broadcast, the Super Bowl XL-winning coach described the unit as “uninspired” and lacking the toughness emblematic of Steelers football, despite a 2-1 record after a gritty 21-14 win over the New England Patriots in Week 3.

“Not only is Aaron Rodgers misplaced, but they’re squandering DK Metcalf’s talent,” Cowher said. “With Rodgers at quarterback and Smith calling plays, this offense looks eerily similar to the Matt Canada days.” He slammed the offensive line’s poor performance, noting, “There’s no rhythm, no toughness, no clear plan. That’s not Steelers football.”

Cowher’s critique comes after Pittsburgh’s heavy offseason investments, including acquiring Rodgers ($20 million/year, 510 career TDs) and Metcalf (3 TDs, 150 yards through three games). Yet, the offense has struggled, with a run game averaging just 3.4 yards per carry. Jaylen Warren managed only 47 yards on 18 carries (2.6 YPC) against the Patriots, while rookie Kaleb Johnson remained benched after a Week 2 miscue. The offensive line, led by Broderick Jones and Troy Fautanu, has allowed seven sacks on Rodgers, prompting concerns about protection.

“This team is lost,” Cowher continued. “Rodgers is one of the all-time greats, but this scheme doesn’t play to his strengths, creating an identity crisis. It’s tough to watch.” Fans echoed his frustration on X, with one post stating, “Cowher’s spot-on—Smith’s offense is a mess!” Others noted parallels to the lackluster Canada era (2021-2023).

The Steelers, battling injuries to Alex Highsmith (ankle), Max Scharping (ACL, out for season), and others, face a critical Week 4 matchup against the 2-1 Minnesota Vikings. Cowher emphasized Pittsburgh’s need for discipline and dominance: “This city expects pride and physicality. If you can’t protect your quarterback or control the line, you’re not living up to the Steelers standard.”

Cowher’s scathing words have intensified scrutiny on Smith and the offense. As the AFC North race heats up, Pittsburgh must find its identity to meet the expectations of a fanbase and a legend demanding excellence.